桑下的评论
-
评STILL ALICE
What if one day I don't remember you, and the feelings of loving you? This is a great book, and the author had done a good research in her academic field. I cried several times while reading this, and I hardly found out this is just a novel until I saw the back cover. Definitely is a book that everyone should read for their families' sake.
-
评宋朝饭局
题材好，作者真心胡扯。我原以为插画是豆瓣上以尊重历史而出名的画家画的，这书也会和历史相符。结果打开看了十来页就气啊。不是说作者没考据，而是作者考据的东西都是些和他主要观点无关的细枝末节，让读者猛地一看，哎呀这书有理有据，然后就忽略了主要观点都是作者自己意淫出来的。而且一本说食物食材的书，通篇参考最多的是宋会要辑稿和东京梦华录，这两本我也不说什么了，但水浒传也能时不时扯出来当论据史学家都是日了狗了！哦，对了，前面我说作者考据，其实算不上，估计就是看了看参考的这俩书，哪个皇帝时都没搞明白，不然也不会说出宋朝牛肉都是屌丝吃的这种无知的话。给这书标注文化我都觉得掉我国文化的份儿，标注饮食史的那位究竟多想不开啊。我看了作者简介，南周专栏作家，怪不得如此“文化”