There is nothing in this book about tape reading. Nothing.
I am a trader. I trade every day, and actually read tape. This poorly written, and unedited assemblage of words is virtually worthless for anyone desirous of becoming a student of tape reading. There is simply no real tape reading content, and the content that resides on these pages is not worth reading, especially if your goal is to become a better trader.
I was intrigued by the title, as you likely are. It seems that when an author has nothing of value to contribute to the trading community, they try to sell their junk by creating a catchy title. It must work to some extent, because the tactic seems to be used a great deal. Read my other reviews for more information.
For some insight into the art of reading tape try, Tape Reading & Market Tactics by Humphrey Neill, and Studies in Tape Reading by Rollo Tape. Both were written long ago, and are valuable contributions to a trader's education. There has been nothing of value written about tape reading in the past 50 years, that I can find.
A final word of advice. Be skeptical of favorable reviews of this book. If you are interested in tape reading, there is nothing here. Also, read reviews written by real traders. For insight into the reviewers' sincerity and discernment, scan all of their reviews. Similar to tape reading and market analysis, one can determine which book reviews to believe and which to ignore from the reviewers' history.
大概意思是:作者讲的看盘技术不是这个样子的。
该书在amazn上的一条书评
对“该书在amazn上的一条书评”的回应
《盘口解读技术》热门书评
-
重在交易理念
8有用 0无用 青原行思 2007-12-11
这是一本很好的书。重点推荐第一章,对于交易者的法则和心态,以及对市场的理解,讲得很到位,对于新手还是老手,都有学习之处,特别是第8节《成熟交易者的法则与心态》,我觉得值得反复阅读。从事交易,核心的是交易的理念,这是高层次的战略,次之为心态和情绪控制,技术只是枝节末梢。所以,先理清楚最重要的东西,再来...
-
该书在amazn上的一条书评
3有用 0无用 hulaa 2010-06-20
There is nothing in this book about tape reading. Nothing. I am a trader. I trade every day, and actually read tape. This poorly written, and unedited...
-
书还不错, 会让你恨死翻译的人
1有用 0无用 uncutstone 2009-07-18
原书的内容是很好的, 翻译的糟糕也是空前的。阅读的快乐是零星稀落的 , 阅读的痛苦是绵绵不断的。翻译者和编辑的不负责任, 实在是触目惊心, 令人发指。 没有办法, 只好到豆瓣喊一嗓子。...
-
其实书也怕叫错名字
1有用 0无用 SMARTMCU 2010-02-26
此书前面8章的心法部分值得多看看,有点大师的感觉,但后面关于图形、技术什么的,往往落入俗套,不看也罢。 另一方面,此书名字太可惜,就它的心法部分,完全可以脱离所谓“技术分析”的范畴。当然我这里没有看低技术分...
-
不值得一买!
0有用 0无用 momoqm 2009-07-26
作者本身的交易趋向于做空!这也就罢了!翻译得实在是够烂!我之所以坚持看完!不过因为其是我完整地正式地看完第一本股票的书籍!...